***Please ensure you are only following official social media accounts for The Redhead Notes. A fake profile has been contacting people on Instagram. Jennie Griffin will never ask you to send money for a book review or to enroll in any programs.

Due to the high volume of requests that have been received, Jennie has temporarily closed submissions. Learn More

Search
Search
Close this search box.
Search
Close this search box.
/ Past Monthly Featured Review

The Girl Who Loved Cayo Bradley

Rating:
5/5

Title: The Girl Who Loved Cayo Bradley

Publication Date: October 21, 2021

Genre: Native American Literature; Western

Cover:

The cover has a dreamy quality with soft hues contrasted against the darker landscape. I love the handwritten title and the fact that it is not capitalized. It lends a sense of nostalgia while also being informal. If I saw this book in a store, I would absolutely pick it up based on the cover alone.

Premise

The Girl Who Loved Cayo Bradley tells the story of Darby McPhee, a teenager living in New Mexico in the 1870s who falls in love with a young man unlike any other, Cayo Bradley. Cayo is a wise beyond his years cowboy caught between two cultures. He was born to a white family but raised by an Apache tribe who he grew to call his family. As Cayo struggles to make peace with his past and dark secrets, Darby struggles to commit to her future and a promise she made to her mother to leave her home in search of an education and a better life.

Why I chose this book:

Author Nina Romano requested this review. Nina is an award-winning novelist with multiple books to her name, and it was an honor to receive her request.

First Impression:

The Girl Who Loved Cayo Bradley is near flawless, and Romano quickly sweeps the reader away to another time and place through her heartfelt storytelling.

What I loved:

Romano is a master at evoking emotion within the reader through the development of her characters, and, in doing so, she allows us to witness their journey and growth as people. I loved seeing Darby and Cayo grow and expand, especially as each struggled to live between two worlds while still being true to their authentic selves. In Darby’s case, we find her caught between wanting to receive an education and wanting to stay tucked away at home with the man she loves. As a small-town girl, she never quite feels at ease in the city. On the other hand, Cayo is caught between two cultures. Yet he cannot live peacefully in either culture as a part of him longs for the other. Each reaches a breaking point in life when they must choose to set aside expectations and stigmas and be true to their dreams, hopes, and desires.

In terms of technical skills, Romano’s ability to write a flashback scene is brilliant. While some authors may use special formatting to indicate a flashback, Romano effortlessly transitions the reader from present to past in a hardly noticeable way. She allows the reader to glide through the character’s memories, reliving the significant moments and then returning to the present.

Additional Thoughts:

As I read, I couldn’t help but think about how decisions we make today, even ones that seem inconsequential, often have the potential to alter the course of our lives forever. This was a theme in The Girl Who Loved Cayo Bradley. Various characters, including Darby and Cayo, made decisions that impacted their lives and those around them. The weight and consequences of these decisions were thoroughly explored throughout the story.

Quotable Quotes:

• It only took that one glance to rivet him in her bones, and to know that he’d be as important as blood coursing through her heart. (Page 1)
• “Stand tall, boy, and remember the important things of life: you’re from strong stock, you have an angel beside you, and everything in this world can be righted with love and forgiveness.” (Page 37)
• Did gaining independence always mean the sacrifice of letting go what was familiar and cherished? Would she ever find a balance for both? (Page 132)
• People were complex beings. Neither all good nor all bad and it was this that fascinated her. (Page 185)
• “Truth and wisdom are like pebbles and stones on the beach,” Mrs. Riggs was fond of saying. “One merely needs to sort them out.” (Page 207)
I’m injured. Inside. A part of me will never heal. I wish I could vomit up all the hurt pulsing in my innards, or run with this demon horse to the end of the world. What have I done? What have I gambled and lost? (Page 260)

Who might enjoy this book:

The Girl Who Loved Cayo Bradley is ideal for readers who enjoy western romance infused with Native American culture.

Overall Impression:

Five Stars. The Girl Who Loved Cayo Bradley can be summed up in one word: superb. Romano proves yet again why she is a loved author and valued member of the writing community. She offers the reader the experience of stepping back in time to witness the complexity of life and relationships in the old west. In doing so, she establishes a love for both the story and characters. This leaves the reader wanting to continue the journey with the next book in the series. This is an outstanding book from an outstanding author!

More...

Read the author's Interview

Read the author's guest post

More
Reviews

/ From The Bookshelf

By Milana Marsenich

5/5
Beautiful Ghost is ideal for readers who enjoy historical fiction highlighting the plight of women in the early 1900s.

By Nina Romano

5/5
Dark Eyes is ideal for readers who enjoy historical fiction with a thrilling mix of mystery and romance.